Saraswati Dharma Coaching
  • Home
  • About Swati
  • Dharma Blog
  • Why Jyotish Astrology?
  • Privacy Policy

What Makes Vedic Astrology So Special?

11/24/2014

1 Comment

 
The Differences Between Eastern and Western Astrology

Part 1.

Jyotish is a Sanskrit word that translates as the study of light (Jyoti means light). Rooted in a tradition that can be traced back thousands of years, Jyotish has a very long history of being a tool of self discovery and awakening.

The knowledge of jyotish is among the numerous Vedic texts. These ancient texts have been largely passed from generation to generation as an oral tradition, yet were originally cognized by enlightened rishis of the past. Eventually the knowledge and wisdom of these rishis was written into the volumes of Vedic texts we know today.

Each of these ancient Vedic texts has a purpose- which is to help humans awaken and become fully realized, enlightened. Although the Hindu religion uses the Vedic texts as resources for their beliefs, the Vedic texts pre-date this organized religion. This is an important distinction to make; the Vedic texts are not in and of themselves a religion, though the Hindu religion is based on them. Thereby, Jyotish is not a religion either.

The Jyotish texts are among the many recognized Vedic texts, and are part of the Angas, or Six Limbs of the Vedas. The Jyotish texts incorporate both astronomy and astrology, and are connected to the eyes, our ability to see; Jyotish is considered the "eye of the Vedas" quite literally. The purpose of the Jyotish texts is to awaken one to their cosmic, divine existence, to truly teach the reality of "as is the macrocosm, so is the microcosm."

The recognized grandfather of Jyotish is considered to be Parashara. He was truly a sage, an enlightened being by all accounts, who lived around 2 to 3,000 B.C. according to Indian historians. It was Parashara who wrote the jyotish texts originally, into what is known today as the Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra. This has been a guiding resource for jyotishis (students of jyotish) for millenniums and is a foundational understanding of Jyotish, the principles, practices and cosmic intelligence that guides our human existence- whether we choose to recognize this phenomenon as reality or not.

The ancient tradition of Eastern astrology, or the sidereal system, has a profound lineage of masters, of seers, that is linked to it; this is unparalleled in the modern, Western astrology realms (also known as Tropical astrology). Though ancient Vedic astrologers were well aware of the difference between the fixed zodiac (sidereal or nirayana chakra in Sanskrit), versus the moveable zodiac (tropical or sayana chakra in Sanskrit), they chose to use the sidereal zodiac for reasons of accuracy. (I will discuss calculations more in part 2 of this article).

Western astrology, the way it is used today is quite new, and it cannot be linked to ancient roots like that of the sidereal approach. I believe this to be the most important distinction between the tropical and sidereal approaches to astrology. I'm a traditionalist in many regards. I want a lineage connected to my knowledge and resources. Lineage is important for me in order to trust the knowledge that I'm receiving. The wisdom and guidance of the ancient Jyotish system provides this for me.

Living in a Westerncentric society, yet having grown up in a yogic family with Eastern philosophy and spiritual ideals instilled into me, I have often contemplated the differences, the clashes, in Western ideals vs. Eastern ideals. Western ideals, in my view, are very rooted in an externalized reality- what we can see, what is "known", what can be "proven" in tangible ways. The West trusts the thinking mind, yet mistrusts the emotional and intuitive aspects of existence. Western ideals are connected to wanting tangible proofs, and there is a generalized mistrust in anything that can't be proven through the West's favorite tool of proof, science. 

In general, these ideals tend to clash with what I've learned from Eastern philosophy and spirituality. The wide gap between Eastern and Western ideals, however, seems to be changing more and more as a result of Westerncentric ideals becoming globalized. However, in my experience, and through my studies of Jyotish, the East by and large accepts the senses, the feeling level of life, in a way the West can't quite grasp. Spiritual existence (not just religious) is an accepted and even essential ingredient for understanding one's life. The spiritual realms are a trustworthy resource and a valid one. Westerncentric ideals on the other hand, tend to question and doubt the unseen realms, and even mistrust the innate intuitive guidance systems hardwired into our human body.

Simply put, the West seems to be mainly concerned with the more tangible realms, that which is outside of ourselves. The West is very concerned with what effects the surface of life will have on an individual's experience in this lifetime. In contrast, the East seems primarily concerned with the intangible as a driving force for one's life experiences. The spiritual realms, one's inner reality, and how these factors will effect one's overall life (and lives) is the primary consideration for all aspects of life according to Eastern ideals. These philosophical distinctions become important when looking at the differences between astrological approaches- Sidereal vs. Tropical- as well as this idea of fixed and unfixed realities.

Essentially, Eastern astrology, the sidereal approach to studying the cosmic self, is based on the fixed reality of life, that which is unchanging. The ancient jyotishis knew that using a fixed zodiac was ideal as this mirrors the essence of our non-changing self, the Atman, or soul. This non-changing expression of reality, of our cosmic existence, is expressed eloquently in the Mahavakyas and can be stated quite simply as tat tvam asi, or thou art That.

In contrast, the Western approach to astrology, or Tropical approach, is based on the moveable, changing reality of life- as is expressed by the fact that these astrologers choose to cast their charts based on the unfixed zodiac. This is a decidedly poignant distinction that I feel truly accentuates the many differences, philosophically and otherwise, between Eastern and Western approaches. As with predominant Westerncentric ideals, there is an obsession with all aspects of life that are not lasting, that are fleeting illusions. The East knows better.

I admittedly have issues with the Western approach to astrology and I do find it a bit irksome and tiresome to be corrected by Tropical astrology followers who claim my posts are wrong. Though this is slightly annoying, the main reason that I am troubled by Western astrology is a result of its historical connections to the time of Ceasar, the Romans, and the Christian religious mandates that still predominate Westerncentric cultural paradigms. I will highlight this here, but there are in fact numerous resources that do a better job of accounting the atrocities of the Greco-Roman cultures and their lasting impact on our sense of time, our measure of time, and the effects this has had on every aspect of our human existence. 

Undoubtedly, Roman rule changed the course of history, of life and cultural ideals, of our modern spiritual and philosophical understandings. We are still working with many of the failings of this historical time period in my opinion. The Julian calendar which was introduced in 46 BC (though Roman calendars were in place prior to this) is really when the recognized calendar shifted from a Moon based calendar (and in many regards a nature based calendar) to a solar based calendar. This may seem insignificant, yet the implications were very serious and lasting.

It is well documented that when the calendar shifted from Moon based, to Sun based, there was also a shift in how the divine feminine and women in general, were perceived, treated and recognized within society. A shift happened during Roman rule and it has cost humanity greatly. This is when the ultimate shift occurred between honoring feminine ideals versus masculine ideals. This is when Western values and philosophies, and the mind, the mental body, became king. This is the historical time period when women, and our innate intuitive gifts, began to be feared and made evil. This is the time when dogmatic, base religious ideals took over, and ultimately suppressed the awareness of cosmic intelligence within every human being. This is when the goddess died, and the male god came into predominant power. 

As a result of this intense shift in consciousness, a deep appreciation, respect and reverence for the divine feminine, the emotional body, and women was lost. I've spent years studying the goddess and how the divine feminine was slowly killed off; killed not only within our cultural and historical understandings, but also killed within our own spirits. This absence, and Her denial, is what I consider to be the most tragic and striking loss for our Westerncentric civilization as a whole.

The issue of the goddess and the divine feminine may seem like a separate concern, not connected to the differences between sidereal and tropical astrology. I, however, see the connection as a striking and important one.
The Vedic tradition recognizes that the energy of the Moon is feminine and has qualities that correlate to the divine feminine within us and also the functioning of the Divine Feminine in Nature as well. The Sun is recognized as a decidedly masculine energetic expression, which expresses itself within us and in Nature as well. (It is not just the Vedic tradition that honors the Moon as the feminine and the Sun as the masculine energy).

Using a solar based calendar and
basing our sense of time on the solar aspects of life, the masculine, negates the importance and the impact the Moon has on our life and on time itself. In fact, the Moon is our most remarkable entity for marking time accurately. The phases of the Moon, the ones we see as the Moon waxes and wanes, are perhaps the most basic expression of the Moon as natural time keeper. In Vedic astrology, the understanding that Moon is our time keeper, is quite elaborate and truly worth studying.

For me, these are all remarkable philosophical distinctions between the Eastern and Western approaches to astrology. As a Vedic astrology scholar (life long student), I never cease to be amazed at the depth, the understanding and the recognition of the feminine that is interwoven into the Vedic knowledge and the understanding of our cosmic existence. The feminine is recognized in fact, as having more importance than the masculine in many ways. For without the Moon, its nurturing qualities, its ability to comfort, support and most importantly, to create, there would be no existence. No mother, no life. The feminine is who brings us life, brings us into being. It's this depth and this foundational understanding, this honoring of the Divine Feminine, that makes Jyotish a premier resource for understanding ourselves, our innate nature, the depths of our cosmic existence.

I will address calculation differences in Part 2. Leave your questions below, and I will try to address them in my next post.


Jyotish References:

Science of Light, Freedom Tobias Cole
Light on Life, Hart Defouw and Robert Svoboda

Want to learn more about transforming your life through jyotish and embodiment work? Schedule a session with me.


Plan your week in tune with nature. Never miss a planetary update. Sign up for my weekly newsletter.

Was this post helpful? Please share it with a friend! Thank you
1 Comment

    The Dharma Blog

    Browse Articles

    The Dharma Circle FB Group

    Join the FB Group

    Podcasts


    Navaratri: Dancing with the Divine Mothers

    How to Find Your Soul's
    True Path

    How Grief can Give you
    More Joy

    Healing Grief and Trauma from a Jyotish Perspective

    I'm Horrible At This + 4 Simple Steps to Get Your Needs Met

    Soma In A Cup {Simple Ayurvedic Recipe for Rejuvenation}

    Why Isn't the Money Flowing?!

    Read Your Jyotish Chart in Five Easy Steps

    Archives

    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013

    Categories

    All
    3 Level Check In
    4 Level Check In
    4 Level Check-in
    8th-house
    Abhijit
    Adhar
    Adharma
    Aditi
    Aditya
    Agni
    Ahirbudhnya
    Ajaikapada
    Akasha
    Akshaya Tritiya
    Alps
    Amavasya
    Anant Chaturdashi
    Ancestors
    Announcements
    Anuradha
    Apas
    Aquarius
    Arda
    Ardra
    Aries
    Articles
    Art Projects
    Aryaman
    Ashlesha
    Ashtami
    Ashvini Kumara
    Ashvini-kumara
    Ashwini
    Astrology.com
    Asuras
    Asvini Kumara
    Asvini-kumara
    Atma
    Atma Karaka
    Ayurveda
    Baseline Statements
    Be You Media
    Bhaga
    Bhagavati
    Bhakti
    Bharani
    Body Centered Expressive Art Therapy
    Body Parts
    Body Wisdom
    Boundaries
    Brahma
    Breath
    Bright Half
    Brihaspati
    Buddha Jayanti
    Buddhapurnima
    Cancer
    Capricorn
    Celebrations
    Chakras
    Chandra
    Charnel Ground
    Chipatis
    Chitra
    Clients
    Combustion
    Conflict
    Cosmic-and-creative-self
    Courage
    Creative Engagement
    Creative Ritual
    Creativity
    Criticvictimeb701f2c8e
    Dance
    Daria Halprin
    Dark
    Dasami
    Dashami
    Debilitated Mars
    Debilitated Mercury
    Debilitated-mercury
    Debilitated Moon
    Debilitated-saturn
    Debilitated Sun
    Debilitated Venus
    Debilitated-venus
    Debt
    Devas
    Devatas
    Dhanishta
    Dhanvantari
    Dharma
    Divine Feminine
    Diwali
    Durga
    Eclipse
    Eclipse Portal
    EFT
    Elephant Journal
    Embodiment
    Emotional Body
    Emotional Body Literacy
    Empowerment
    Exalted Jupiter
    Exalted Mars
    Exalted Mercury
    Exalted Moon
    Exalted Saturn
    Exalted Sun
    Exalted Venus
    Fall Equinox
    Father
    Feet
    Fire
    First Chakra
    Foot
    Full Moon
    Full Moon In Libra
    Full Moon In Virgo
    Full Moon Wisdom
    Gandanta
    Ganesha
    Ganesha Chaturthi
    Ganga
    Ganga Dashahara
    Gayatri Mantra
    Gemini
    Gifts
    Goals
    Goddess
    Gratitude
    Grief
    Guru
    Guru Purnima
    Gut
    Gutbelly6f2d9eb2da
    Haiku
    Hands And Arms
    Hanuman
    Hanuman-jayanti
    Hasta
    Healing
    Heart Wisdom
    Heyam Dukham Anagatam
    Holi
    Horoscopes
    Houses
    Illusions
    Indra
    Indragni
    Jala
    June Yagyas
    Jupiter
    Jupiter Direct
    Jupiter-in-cancer
    Jupiter-in-cancer
    Jupiter In Gemini
    Jupiter In Leo
    Jupiter In Virgo
    Jupiter Retrograde
    Jyeshta
    Jyestha
    Jyotish Basics
    Kala Sarpa Yoga
    Kali
    Kali Yuga
    Karma
    Kartik Purnima
    Ketu
    Ketu In Pisces
    Kitchari
    Knees
    Krishna
    Krishna Janmashtami
    Krishna Paksha
    Krittika
    Kundalini
    Lagna
    Lakshmi
    Landscape
    Legs
    Leo
    Libra
    Light
    Lord Rama
    Love
    Lunar Eclipse
    Ma
    Magha
    Magic
    Mahishasura
    Makar Sankranti
    Makar-sankranti
    Mandala
    Manifestation
    Mars
    Mars In Aries
    Mars In Cancer
    Mars In Leo
    Mars In Libra
    Mars In Scorpio
    Mars In Virgo
    Mars Retro
    Mask Work
    Mental Body
    Mercury
    Mercury Direct
    Mercury In Aries
    Mercury In Cancer
    Mercury In Capricorn
    Mercury In Gemini
    Mercury In Leo
    Mercury In Libra
    Mercury In Pisces
    Mercury In Sagittarius
    Mercury In Scorpio
    Mercury In Taurus
    Mercury In Virgo
    Mercury Retro
    Mercury Retrograde
    Mercury Saturn Conjunction
    Mitra
    Money
    Moon
    Moon Diagnosis
    Moon In Virgo
    Moon Min
    Moon Mind
    Moon-mind
    Moon Mind Calendar
    Moon Wisdom
    Moon Wisdom Calendar
    Mother Divine
    Mrgashiras
    Mrigashirsha
    Mula
    Naga
    Nakshatra Assessment
    Nakshatras
    Navami
    Navaratri
    Navratri
    Neck
    New Moon
    New Moon Gemini
    New Moon Libra
    New Moon Wisdom
    New Year
    Nirrti
    Nritti
    Ocean Of Milk
    Online-events
    Parashara
    Passion
    Pelvis
    Penumbral Eclipse
    Pisces
    Pitr
    Planetary Transits
    Podcast
    Podcasts
    Poems
    Polarities
    Prajapati
    Prana
    Pujanetc7cedf5218
    Pulse Dance
    Punarvasu
    Purification
    Purnima
    PurvaAshada
    Purvabhadrapada
    Purvaphalguni
    Pushan
    Pushya
    Rahu
    Rahu-in-virgo
    Rahu-in-virgo
    Ram Navami
    Rasi
    Recipes
    Relationships
    Resiliency
    Resources
    Retrograde Jupiter
    Retrogradejupiter
    Retrograde Mars
    Retrograde-mars
    Retrograde Mercury
    Retrograde Venus
    Retrograde-venus
    Retrogradevenus
    Revati
    Ribcage
    Ribcase
    Rohini
    Rsvp
    Rudra
    Saas Fee
    Sagittarius
    Sandhi
    Saraswati
    Sarpa
    Satabhisha
    Satabisha
    Saturn
    Saturn Conjunct Mars
    Saturn In Sagittarius
    Saturn In Scorpio
    Saturn Rahu Conjunction
    Saturn Retrograde
    Savitr
    Scorpio
    Second Chakra
    Self Care
    Self Love
    Self Tracking
    Senses
    Sensitivity
    Services And Offerings
    Servicesandofferings
    Sessions-consults
    Sessionsconsults
    Sessions Consults9659814dae
    Shadows
    Shakti
    Shiva
    Shivaratri
    Shukla Paksha
    Shuklapaksha
    Sidereal Astrology
    Signs
    Singing
    Sixth-house
    Solar Eclipse
    Soma
    Soul
    Spine
    Spiritual Bypassing
    Spring Equinox
    Spring-equinox
    Sravana
    Storms
    Suklanta
    Summer Solstice
    Sun
    Sun In Cancer
    Sun In Gemini
    Sun In Leo
    Sun In Pisces
    Sun In Sagittarius
    Sun In Scorpio
    Sun In Taurus
    Sun In Virgo
    Sun Mercury Conjunction
    Sun Sign
    Surya
    Swati
    Swati Jr Jewelry
    Tamalpa
    Tapas
    Taurus
    Tejas
    Testimonials
    The Critic
    The Emergent
    Three-steps
    Thriving
    Throat And Jaw
    Tithi 1
    Tithi-10
    Tithi 13
    Tithi 14
    Tithi 15
    Tithi15
    Tithi 2
    Tithi 3
    Tithi 4
    Tithi 5
    Tithi 7
    Tithi 8
    Tithi 9
    Transits
    Trayodashi
    Tropical Astrology
    Twelfth-house
    Upanishad
    Uttarabhadrapada
    Uttaraphalguni
    Uttarashada
    Vaidya Rama Kant Mishra
    Varuna
    Vasant-navaratri
    Vasu
    Vasudeva
    Vasu Devas
    Vayu
    Venus
    Venus In Aries
    Venus In Cancer
    Venus In Gemini
    Venus In Leo
    Venus In Libra
    Venus In Pisces
    Venus In Scorpio
    Venus In Taurus
    Vijayadashami
    Virgo
    Vishaka
    Vishnu
    Vishvadeva
    Vishvakarma
    Visvadeva
    Vulnerability
    Waning Moon
    Waningmoon
    Warrior
    Water
    Water Color
    Waxing Moon
    Waxingmoon
    Wealth
    Winter Solstice
    Winter-solstice
    Workshops
    Yagyas
    Yajur Veda
    Yama
    Yoga
    Zen

All content on this website is sole property of Saraswati Embodied Dharma Coaching  unless otherwise noted and may not be reproduced without permission or consent. Please be aware that legal action will be taken if content is used without permission or credit.
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • About Swati
  • Dharma Blog
  • Why Jyotish Astrology?
  • Privacy Policy