Saraswati Dharma Coaching
  • Home
  • About Swati
  • Dharma Blog
  • Why Jyotish Astrology?
  • Privacy Policy

Why Western Astrology is Inaccurate.

8/14/2018

2 Comments

 
Picture


As a Vedic Astrologer, one of the most common questions I hear is:

What is Vedic Astrology? How is it different from "regular" astrology?

Most Westerners don't even know there is more accurate form of astrology and they have no idea that Eastern astrology, or Vedic Astrology, predates the Western approach to astrological interpretation. Some people truly don't care that they are ingesting cosmic misrepresentations and half truths.

Even more surprising to me is the fact that many Westerners who study yoga fail to deepen their knowledge of the Vedic Limbs- which includes a branch called Jyotish, or Vedic Astrology. Every branch of the Vedas contains resources for awakening, or enlightenment. Vedic astrology, or Jyotish, is a powerful resource for increasing the light of awareness, jyoti.

Many people who learn the differences between Western and Eastern astrology, realize that they have studied false information for years. Western, or Tropical astrology, simply put, is highly inaccurate. Yet it predominates as the mainstream understanding of astrology in the West. As surprising as this is, it speaks volumes about Westerncentric interpretations of knowledge and wisdom.

The depth, layers and ancient lineage of jyotish astrology are incomparable. Simply put, the West has nothing like it. But there are even more glaring differences between Jyotish (or Sidereal astrology) and Tropical (or Western astrology).

There are two ways of measuring the zodiac- a Tropical approach and a Sidereal approach. The different measurements are an important distinction to understand. The Sidereal zodiac is based on the fixed sky, the stars- which do not move.  Whereas the Tropical zodiac is based on the moveable, unfixed sky, and uses the constantly changing vernal equinox for its measurements.

Besides the metaphoric differences of a fixed vs. unfixed zodiac, there is an even more  important difference that determines the fate of accuracy. The Eastern Sidereal system is astronomically accurate because it uses the Sun's position in relation to the skies. Planetary movement is tracked against the fixed position of the stars- which honors astral positions accurately.

The Western Tropical zodiac is based on the relationship of the Sun to the Earth. It tracks planetary movement from the view point of the Earth, and tracks the planets from seasonal points, like spring time and the equinox.

The differences between these two zodiacs sounds fine in theory, however, it creates an unfortunate problem when calculating the starting point of the zodiac. Where the zodiac begins is crucial for constructing an accurate chart. Accuracy must be based on the reality of what is happening in the skies. Both systems agree there are twelve signs, but because a difference has emerged in the starting point of the zodiac, the Sidereal zodiac and the Tropical zodiacs no longer align. The ancient Vedic astrologers understood the differences in these two zodiacs and chose not to use a Tropical approach because they knew it wasn't accurate.

Tropical astrology marks the beginning of its zodiac from the seasonal point, or vernal equinox. However due to complex astronomical shifts taking place, the point of the vernal equinox changes slightly every year at a rate of about one degree every 72 years. Over the last several hundred years, the starting point of the astrological year has changed as a result. The Sidereal system takes this shift into consideration, however, the Tropical system does not. As a result, there is now roughly a 24 degree discrepancy between starting points of the Tropical and Sidereal zodiacs.

Tropical astrology doesn't take into consideration the slight but consistent shift taking place annually between our earthly position in relation to the Sun. Over hundreds of years, this 24 degree shift has slowly been taking place and the starting point of the seasons (or equinox) has continued to change as well. Eventually this difference will become so large that Western astrology will become obsolete and will no longer have any relevance. Currently there is little to no connection between the Tropical zodiac and what is happening astronomically in the skies.

Eastern astrology on the contrary is astronomically accurate because it is consistently taking into consideration the current placement of the Sun in relation to the skies. It is therefor an accurate expression of what is happening cosmically from the vantage point of the sky and star patterns, or constellations. The consistent and slow shift in seasons, our relationship to the Sun, and the placement of the planets in relation to the stars, is all utilized in order to create a true expression of the cosmos.

The starting point of the zodiac is important for an accurate chart to be pulled. After hundreds of years, Western astrology is still calling Aries the starting point of the zodiac and uses the same start date every year- even though it is no longer relevant. But due to the slow and steady astronomical shifts taking place, Aries is actually not an accurate starting point any more. The 24 degree shift (which continues to widen) is accounted for in Eastern calculations. Currently, according to Sidereal calculations, the zodiac begins at about six degrees Pisces.


Besides the way the charts are cast, the differences between Eastern and Western astrology are vast. The depth, layers, intention, philosophy, as well as the spiritual and dharmic clarity of Vedic astrology, far surpasses anything that Western astrology can offer- hands down.


Read More About the Differences Between Eastern and Western Astrology.

Jyotish Astrology Basics
~ for Transformation and Healing


Still struggling to read your own jyotish chart?


Are you seeking clarity, insights and wisdom for your healing path?

Searching for your purpose and life path clarity?

Wanting spiritual answers and an expanded understanding of your self?

Wishing you could trust your self and your path more fully?

Disappointed & dissatisfied with the astrological resources you've found so far?

Desiring more depth, feminine wisdom, and a holistic approach to Vedic Astrology?


Ready to finally learn the foundational pieces of your Jyotish chart so you can go deeper?


My Jyotish Basics Classes for Transformation and Healing are just for you!

GET THE DETAILS HERE


Level 2 Begins September 1st!!



EARLY BIRD PRICING ENDS SEPTEMBER 4th!!


*** ONLY 5 Spots Left !! ***


REGISTER NOW


I call myself the Dharma Midwife.

I
am on a mission to help sensitive souls connect with their inner truth and inner wisdom. To connect with purpose and dharma. We need you now more than ever!

Every week I offer two *free* dharma coaching sessions to action takers who are ready for deep life change. Is this you?!

Send me a message to see if I have any openings: [email protected]
​

2 Comments
Laura Plumb link
8/28/2018 03:33:36 pm

Thank you for writing this very detailed article. While I have always respected both eastern and western sciences, I agree - it is so surprising to me that Yogis choose western astrology. So surprising! Thanks and big love.

Reply
swati
1/1/2020 10:46:59 am

Thank you for commenting Laura. It is surprising isn't it?! Old habits die hard and let's face it, Vedic Astrology is quite complex!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.


    The Dharma Blog

    Browse Articles

    Are you an experienced healer ready for a 6 figure business and clarity with your dharmic purpose?

    Join the Dharma Circle FB Group
    Join the FB Group

    Podcasts


    Articles


    Picture
    10 Signs You Are Radically Aligned With Your Path and Purpose!!!

    Picture
    Why Your Pricing Matters + Four Ways to Create Pricing That Feels Good

    Picture
    The Wisdom of Rahu and Ketu ~for your Dharma Path

    Picture
    My Ketu Maha Dasha Experience and Why I'm Celebrating Now

    Picture
    The Nine Phases of Your Dharmic Path

    Picture
    Mercury Retrograde:
    It's Not What You Think

    Picture
    The Sensitive Soul
    Survival Guide- for Work

    This is Why You Aren't Healing

    Picture
    Why Western Astrology
    Is Inaccurate


    Picture
    Jyotish Astrology Basics ~
    ~ for Transformation
    and Healing

    Picture
    Four Signs Your
    ​Relationships Won't Last

    Picture
    Six Ways to Feed
    the Ancestors

    Picture
    Six Reasons Why Jyotish Astrology Will Change
    ​Your Life Forever

    Picture
    How the Dark Goddess Destroys Your Dharmic Path

    Picture
    The Power of Your
    ​First Chakra

    Picture
    Dharma Awakening: Step 1
    Planting Seeds

    Picture
    Are You Sensitive?
    Here's How to Tell

    Picture
    Grief, the Maha Guru

    Picture
    Transform Your Challenges

    Picture
    Why Money Is Your Best Spiritual Resource + Podcast

    Picture
    How to Read Your Jyotish Chart ~ In Five Easy Steps

    Archives

    June 2022
    February 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015

    Categories

    All
    14 Day Challenge
    Adharma
    Aditi
    Agni
    Ahirbudhnya
    Ajai Ekapada
    Akshaya Tritiya
    Akshaya Trittiya
    Amavasya
    Ancestors
    Anger
    Anuradha
    Apas
    Ardra
    Articles
    Aryaman
    Ashlesha
    Ashwini
    Ayurveda
    Bhaga
    Bharani
    Brahma
    Breath
    Brihaspati
    Buddha Jayanti
    Buddha Purnima
    Cancer
    Chakras
    Chitra
    Classes
    Creative Ritual
    Creative Ritual Class
    Dashas
    Debilitated Jupiter
    Debilitated Mercury
    Debilitated Moon
    Debts
    Dhanishta
    Dhanvantari
    Dharma
    Dharma Summit
    Dharmic Mentorship
    Divine Feminine
    Diwali
    Durga
    Eclipse Portal
    EFT
    Embodiment
    Emotional Body
    Empowerment
    Exalted Moon
    Exalted Sun
    Feet
    First Chakra
    Four Level Check In
    Full Moon
    Gandanta
    Ganesha Chaturthi
    Goddess
    Goddess Lakshmi
    Goddess Saraswati
    Gratitude
    Grief
    Guru
    Guru Purnima
    Hanuman
    Hanuman Jayanti
    Hasta
    Healing
    Healing + Transformation
    Holi
    Horoscopes
    Indra
    Indragni
    Jupiter In Capricorn
    Jupiter In Libra
    Jupiter In Sagittarius
    Jupiter In Scorpio
    Jupiter In Virgo
    Jupiter Retrograde
    Jyestha
    Jyotish
    Jyotish Basics
    Kala Amrita Yoga
    Kala Sarpa Yoga
    Karma
    Ketu
    Ketu In Aquarius
    Ketu In Capricorn
    Ketu In Sagittarius
    Ketu In Scorpio
    Ketu Maha Dasha
    Krittika
    Lakshmi
    Libra
    Life Purpose
    Lord Ram
    Love
    Lunar Eclipse
    Lunar New Year
    Lunar Nodes
    Ma Durga
    Magha
    Maha Membership
    Makar Sankranti
    Mandala
    Manifestation
    Mars Direct
    Mars In Aquarius
    Mars In Aries
    Mars In Capricorn
    Mars In Gemini
    Mars In Libra
    Mars In Pisces
    Mars In Sagittarius
    Mars In Scorpio
    Mars Retrograde
    Mercury Direct
    Mercury In Aquarius
    Mercury In Aries
    Mercury In Cancer
    Mercury In Capricorn
    Mercury In Gemini
    Mercury In Leo
    Mercury In Libra
    Mercury In Pisces
    Mercury In Sagittarius
    Mercury In Scorpio
    Mercury In Taurus
    Mercury In Virgo
    Mercury Retrograde
    Mitra
    Money
    Moon Calendar
    Moon Mind Calendar
    Moon Wisdom
    Mrigashirsha
    Mula
    Navaratri
    New Moon
    Ninth House
    Nirrti
    Nourishment
    Pelvis
    Penumbral Eclipse
    Pisces
    Pitr
    Podcasts
    Polarities
    Punarvasu
    Purnima
    PurvaAshada
    Purvabhadra
    Purvaphalguni
    Pushan
    Pushya
    Rahu
    Rahu And Ketu
    Rahu In Cancer
    Rahu In Gemini
    Rahu In Leo
    Rahu In Taurus
    Ram Navami
    Recipes
    Relationships
    Revati
    Ritual
    Rohini
    Rudra
    Sade Sati
    Sandhi
    Sanskrit
    Sarpa
    Satabisha
    Saturn
    Saturn Direct
    Saturn In Capricorn
    Saturn In Sagittarius
    Saturn In Scorpio
    Saturn Retrograde
    Savitr
    Self Care
    Self Love
    Self Sabotage
    Sensitivity
    Shadow
    Shadow Planets
    Shakti
    Shivaratri
    Solar Eclipse
    Solstice
    Soma
    Spine
    Sravana
    Sun In Aquarius
    Sun In Cancer
    Sun In Capricorn
    Sun In Gemini
    Sun In Leo
    Sun In Libra
    Sun In Pisces
    Sun In Sagittarius
    Sun In Scorpio
    Sun In Taurus
    Sun In Virgo
    Swati
    Tapping Meditation
    Transformation
    Transits
    UttaraAshada
    UttaraBhadra
    Uttaraphalguni
    Varuna
    Vasant Panchami
    Vasu Devas
    Vedic Celebrations
    Vedic Lunar New Year
    Vedic New Year
    Venus
    Venus In Aquarius
    Venus In Aries
    Venus In Cancer
    Venus In Capricorn
    Venus In Gemini
    Venus In Leo
    Venus In Libra
    Venus In Pisces
    Venus In Sagittarius
    Venus In Scorpio
    Venus In Taurus
    Venus In Virgo
    Venus Retrograde
    Vernal Equinox
    Videos
    Vijaya Dashami
    Vishaka
    Vishnu
    Vishva Devas
    Vishvakarma
    Waning Moon
    Warrior
    Waxing Cycle
    Waxing Moon
    Western Astrology
    Winter Solstice
    Yama

    RSS Feed

All content on this website is sole property of Saraswati Embodied Dharma Coaching  unless otherwise noted and may not be reproduced without permission or consent. Please be aware that legal action will be taken if content is used without permission or credit.
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • About Swati
  • Dharma Blog
  • Why Jyotish Astrology?
  • Privacy Policy